Leaving Mormonism, But Still Not Sure

I am a 23 year old male born and raised in the LDS church. My family has always been and is very strong in the church. My mother was raised catholic and converted around the age of 21 to the LDS religion. This happened just before my father returned home from his mission. My father’s mother was LDS but his father was not. I lived almost all of my life in the San Francisco area of California. Unlike most of the exit stories I have read, I did not grow up in a town where Mormons were abundant. Rather, I was the minority. This left me out of various childhood activities (weekend birthday sleep-overs and swim team competitions).

I had a picture perfect childhood. As I have matured and learned more of the typical life of non-members I have quickly realized that I have always lived on easy street. Even though it seemed like my life was filled with trials and tribulations; I was really living in an ideal household. This is something that I do recognize that the Mormon teachings have given my family. Although these days I do not believe in the theology of the LDS church; I do believe that it can build strong morals and families.

Early on I think my desire to not be a Mormon was fueled by being that odd man out. At school and other activities there was very rarely anyone who shared this lifestyle with me. When age 8 arrived I recall going through all the interviews and such to prepare me for my official entrance into the LDS church. This is something that I now have a problem with. LDS doctrine teaches that the reason children are not baptized at birth is because they feel that age 8 is the time of self-accountability. Well, at 8 years old, the last thing I want to do is NOT get baptized. The fear of being an outcast in my family and amongst my ward is a terrifying thought. Children are constantly reassured that the choice to be baptized is their’s. Well, I can’t imagine any child who is raised from day 1 to believe everything that the church teaches; deny official membership at age 8. So, obviously I was baptized.

My father always held many positions in the ward and at one time was my scoutmaster. By the age of 16 I was very close to getting my eagle but stopped caring about the program and never finished. My father also became my bishop in my high school years. But first let’s jump back a little bit to my junior high years. I believe this is when I started to doubt the church. Just before high school I remember going to education week and I started listening to tapes of various LDS motivational youth speakers. Forgive me for not recalling who said this but the phrase “wax strong” is something that became a mantra to me. I believed if that I held strong to the rod, Satan could not tempt me.

I always pictured myself as one who would never get into the use of drugs and alcohol. By the time I entered high school, that all changed. I quickly began recreational use of marijuana with 2 other LDS youth that I grew up with. I guess that is odd that member and not non-members were the ones that first experimented with. I soon started dabbling in hallucinogens and seeking a deeper understanding of the universe and a higher state of consciousness. I currently do not advocate the use of drugs but I feel that some of the mental journeys I went on ultimately led me to “think outside the box”. By this time, my future in the LDS church was very over. It wasn’t that I felt I wasn’t worthy but I think something deep inside me felt that what I was taught my whole life was nothing more than a delusion. I recall breaking the bread during the sacrament and thinking to myself “these are the same hands that committed sin last night”. If I was sinning like this and still performing my duties in disguise, who else in the church was?

I am still the black sheep of my family. Actually I prefer to not think of myself as a sheep at all. Sheep blindly follow and do not question. High school was a very rough time for me and my relationship with my family. I faithfully attended seminary every morning before school. My freshman year I got very sick. I would wake up at 5, go to seminary at 6, go to school at 7, go to wrestling practice after until 6 and then come home with no energy to study. By my junior year, I was working a job in which I was stealing products on a regular basis to sell to my peers. I was eventually caught and charged with 2 felonies. It was my choice to spend my senior year at a boarding school in central Utah (about 1 hour south of Provo). I felt that some time spent there would get me away from my parents and allow me to prove to the courts that I wasn’t a bad kid. I really wasn’t a bad kid; I just had made some poor choices.

Up until this point my lack of interest in the church was purely being sick of hearing the same stuff being drilled into my head. If there is a definition of brainwashing, this was it. I felt like I knew the answers to all the questions in my religious classes without even thinking. That was the problem, I wasn’t really thinking about what it all meant and to be honest I didn’t care. I would try to come home early from church and my mom would come home and demand me to return to church. To her, church wasn’t an option. It was something that everyone in our family did. This really hit hard to me. I felt that religious faith is something that can’t be forced.

I have always been creative and artistic. Early in high school I knew I wanted to study at a college where I could take art and computer related courses. I found that Academy of Art in San Francisco was really the way to go. Unfortunately this school was very expensive. My parents’ suggestion was to go to a cheaper school first to complete my general education choices. My brother expressed interest in BYU Hawaii and so I agreed to apply. Although by this time I was very far from the church I figured that it was Hawaii and it could be THAT bad. Well I got accepted and my brother got married and decided to stay at BYU Idaho. I really didn’t want to go to a Mormon school by myself. I think my parents hoped that this Mormon environment would inspire me to serve a mission. Both of my older brothers served missions but I had decided long before this time that serving was not in my future. My first year in Hawaii was very depressing. To be honest I was annoyed by most members and found that I did not connect with them at all. I wanted to come home after my first semester. My parents insisted that I stay a whole year. In the last 2 months I finally made some friends that I could connect with.

I reluctantly decided to stay a 2nd year. This time I lived off campus and was back into my partying mode. I very rarely attended church. I basically attended just enough that my leaders wouldn’t complain and threaten to kick me out. By the end of my 2nd year I decided that I couldn’t live the lie any longer. I moved back to California and began my journey into religious discovery.

As I had mentioned before, I didn’t initially walk away from the church because of things I had read about the origins of the church. I had just simply always felt that there was something that didn’t connect with me. I recall many emotional conversations with my parents as a youth. I would tell them that the LDS church was their religion and not mine. This was not something they could understand. They would ask, “What do you believe in then?” This is something I could not answer at the time but I feel that I can answer now.

I would say that for the past year or more, my relationship with God is stronger than ever. I do not attend any church at the moment. Almost every exit story I have read, the person has converted to another Christian religion. My experience was more of a journey from Mormonism to hitting rock bottom to picking myself up and re-evaluating the history of the world and the universe. I do not consider myself to be an Atheist. I guess I would categorize myself as Agnostic. I believe that the universe is a fascinating place and that there must be a higher purpose to life. There is not a day that goes by that my brain deeply ponders EVERYTHING. This is why I say my relationship is closer to God than ever before. I feel that in my youth I was going through the motions but didn’t really have a strong relationship with my heavenly father.

Growing up we are taught to fear and avoid any publications that challenge the church. I recall the film “God’s Army” where there is an elder who starts reading anti-Mormon literature. He is depicted as the crazy one and that any doubt he has is associated with mental instability. But he even says things in the movie that ultimately lead me to want to know more about the TRUE history of the church. He mentions something about horses not being native to the Americas and a few other things. I remember thinking, if this is the most accurate book ever, than how is science and history disproving most of it’s claims?

This is why I have not converted to another Christian religion. I feel there are flaws in Christianity and Mormonism. One of the biggest things that have always befuddled me is some of the tall tales the Bible tells. Noah built a huge ship and put 2 of every animal on it. Ok, first of all the WHOLE earth has never been flooded at once. Another thing is that it has been proven that the technology of the time could not build boats the size the Bible describes. Boats were more like 10ft square boxes that floated. Another story is Jonah, how could a man be swallowed by a whale and live to tell about it? Or how about Moses? There are multiple instances where he displays the awesome power of God. Why do all of these things occur in the Bible and nothing like it has happened since? Is it possible that true stories were exaggerated in the Bible? In my Anthropology class at BYU Hawaii, one of the only moments I stayed awake in class I remember my professor saying something that has really stuck with me. He said that history has what experts call the ‘telescope effect’. That is that the further back you go, the understanding of what really happened becomes fuzzy. Before the invention of paper and widespread use of writing, stories were told verbally from one person to another. We all know the classic telephone game. The initial story or phrase when it gets to the end of the line can end up very different. So is it possible that even biblical history was prone to this effect?

These are the types of questions I go through in my head constantly. If there was a pre-existence then that would mean that there is basically a numbered amount of souls that need to come to earth. So if one has an abortion, does that mean that the soul that was designated for that fetus never has an opportunity for terrestrial life? What about those who are born ‘vegetables’? These people never grow as the rest of us do. Does that mean that they are free from sin and are guaranteed a place in heaven? If and when the 2nd coming happens, is that dependant on the repository of souls running out? Once everyone has a chance to be here then new babies can’t be born with a soul?

Mormons believe that one day we can all be gods if live worthy of such a blessing. I have been told that is why education is important. Everything we learn here will be carried on. However I believe that the church stunts this desire to know as much as possible. We are taught that science can answer very little about the existence of the universe and us. I place a lot of faith in science and math. The earth is not flat, there is no one living in the clouds and stars are just other suns and planets like those in our solar system. We know the approximate age of our planet and solar system. Mormonism and Christianity presume that the earth is only 6,000 years old. Way off compared to what scientists KNOW. I do not believe that life started in some garden with one man and one woman. Evolution is very much a proven fact. As I mentioned before I am not an Atheist. I believe science, math and physics are the answer to how and not why. The why part is something man has been asking forever. This is why we have so many religions in the world.

When early man watched the rising and setting of the sun; it must have been such a magical experience. Today we know why it rises and sets. This is why religions that believe there is a sun god or moon god are more or less extinct. No one believes in Egyptian or Greek theologies anymore. But for some reason there are some religions that still remain strong. I believe that all religions that have ever existed have been man-made. They are our theories of our purpose in this life and the possibility of life after death. If there is a higher power in this universe, he never has or will talk to us. I feel and psychology studies have proved that if you wish hard enough to believe in something, you will. The mind is a powerful thing and we have to use logic and reason to come to conclusions. Not blind faith.

Something that sparked my interest in reading more about the true history of the church was 2 events that happened at about the same time. The first was when I was attending BYU Hawaii. Some girls that I was close friends with at the school (who were also “bad Mormons”) stopped me one time and asked if I really knew what went on in the temple. Well, I had done baptisms for the dead before but beyond that I was quite clueless. They proceeded to tell me about some of the anointing rituals and the infamous gestures that symbolized slitting your throat and disemboweling oneself. This came as quite a shock to me. I had no idea that some of these ceremonies were so abstract. The other event was the airing of a particular South Park episode. One of the creators was raised LDS and fell away from it. They created an episode that bluntly told the history of the church. I never knew that Joseph Smith mostly read the translations out of a hat. After watching this TV episode it was quite obvious how silly and sad it was that so many people believed in something that was essentially made up.

I soon began researching online and trying to understand the truth for myself. I learned of the connections between Masonic rituals and the founding of the LDS church. This quickly led to a Pandora’s box of information that I had never been exposed to.

So here I am living every day mostly content with life. I have a family that I know wishes I would see the light and return to the church so that we can be an eternal family. I have never been married and according to the doctrine if I don’t do so in the temple I will never go to the highest kingdom. Well, I have never believed that when one goes to heaven, God will say “sorry you aren’t Mormon and that isn’t good enough”. God is too big for just one religion or answer. I feel that existence of man is an ongoing learning process. Matter and energy is never destroyed. I believe this is the same for our souls. I guess you could say I believe in reincarnation. When one dies their energy and consciousness is transferred to the next existence of life. Nothing is ever lost in the universe and their certainly is not a limited amount of souls that can receive a body. I believe that the longer we keep constantly questioning EVERYTHING that science will lead us back to religion and explanation to the BIG question.

Religion provides lots of people in this world with happiness and a sense of peace. I do recognize that the Mormon religion created a mostly healthy environment for me as a child. While I do not believe it is necessary to have religion to create a strong set of moral values, I do believe that it certainly helps. The Bible may not be literally true but it has a lot of stories with good morals.